{"board_id":"writing","published_at":"2026-11-13T03:41:02+00:00","revision":"axis-release-0078f6c0-ac80-453e-a7b9-9a7beeba8079","rows":[{"configuration_id":"sha256:79debd7fd28424b893a0f1d3a67d6253337cd48fcb49e873d63d51db8cd8af32","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Gemini 4 Carbon","model_id":"gemini-4-carbon","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:cf901d011a2f117db8f6beb12ce4b41ae8496ac91e13244cc46884635408ade9","reasoning_effort":"high","result_id":"result-7d44d897-61a0-557b-b7be-56d3b12c9aad","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":89.0909090909091},"understanding":{"score":99.0909090909091}},"score":94.0909090909091,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":100},"内容完成度":{"score":75},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":89.16666666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":97.5},"结构与推进":{"score":95.83333333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:97ef72d14acbfa14be9243e0680745d30c938e08dd917d3143e1746888e3071c","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Claude Opus 5.5","model_id":"claude-opus-5-5","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-1c0cdd4b-c7b7-5109-ae34-30cd9da71841","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":86.80397727272727},"understanding":{"score":85.53030303030303}},"score":86.16714015151516,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":82.109375},"内容完成度":{"score":80.20833333333333},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":91.66666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":85.83333333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":89.375},"结构与推进":{"score":97.5},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:2f0439e461db4f5341c3034b2aa451bdc6ac2f436c9bd74b5f24087673eeeacc","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Muse Wonder","model_id":"muse-wonder","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-f79b3006-ca90-5f94-ba2d-75ce5ea06402","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":76.23863636363636},"understanding":{"score":91.51515151515152}},"score":83.87689393939394,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":60.6875},"内容完成度":{"score":65.07291666666667},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":84.82291666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":76.66666666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":89.1875},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:a83ac91cce7644e44407babb825360c135cc716c12190835eeca00a8773f4f7b","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Gemini 4 Argon","model_id":"gemini-4-argon","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"high","result_id":"result-cfe9c28d-bd07-56cf-b621-947eaa78b18d","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":72.82102272727273},"understanding":{"score":93.03030303030303}},"score":82.92566287878788,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":62.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":71.5625},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":69.19791666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":85},"结构与推进":{"score":84.72916666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:4eebee3197ce8b0a06383e144f6bd090d37f8b4c1d2e08626378b5f0ed29f7f0","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Claude Sonnet 5.5","model_id":"claude-sonnet-5-5","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max+high","result_id":"result-c9f9429d-100d-5047-a4e7-4ce080b9bc87","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":79.32954545454545},"understanding":{"score":84.92424242424242}},"score":82.12689393939394,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":73.6875},"内容完成度":{"score":75.72916666666667},"意图与语境":{"score":83.33333333333333},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":82.15625},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":91.875},"结构与推进":{"score":83.86458333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:156693c6330e075c06e0855c3df69540a85389e0a7a0fba0d9456486594417c3","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-6 Astra","model_id":"gpt-6-astra","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-d165d083-544d-558f-8b38-6cf3354e5a96","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":92.63352272727273},"understanding":{"score":70.9090909090909}},"score":81.77130681818181,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":91},"内容完成度":{"score":93.48958333333333},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":88.83333333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":74.16666666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":96.66666666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":33.333333333333336}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:9e269f95fde2a5508c462364e0c822aae99b46ab86141da985c713368e80141d","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Qwen3.8-Max","model_id":"qwen3.8-max","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"xhigh","result_id":"result-6f267211-632e-59fd-9657-c096469ab416","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":70.33806818181819},"understanding":{"score":90.60606060606061}},"score":80.47206439393939,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":65.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":66.45833333333333},"意图与语境":{"score":83.33333333333333},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":70.125},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":82.5},"结构与推进":{"score":77.80208333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:f0b2e04ecf9ee031cd50fbed533cc21e24d09912216c135c33fcbf28845957a2","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-6.1 Terra","model_id":"gpt-6.1-terra","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-d407f01d-80c4-56ae-83d5-9a1f67497fc8","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":84.98011363636364},"understanding":{"score":74.31818181818181}},"score":79.64914772727273,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":81.25},"内容完成度":{"score":78.95833333333333},"意图与语境":{"score":85.41666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":83.72916666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":61.666666666666664},"结构与推进":{"score":94.73958333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:1c27ea31d9a019aaf4c9a8e381693c6f7b43ae51232483b475c3f9c2a115ab1e","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Grok 4.7","model_id":"grok-4.7","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"xhigh","result_id":"result-d7e146ba-2352-54d0-a090-488de10b3498","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":76.9715909090909},"understanding":{"score":79.6969696969697}},"score":78.3342803030303,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":63.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":69.375},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":66.66666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":85.64583333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":65},"结构与推进":{"score":85.02083333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:f24e6ecf34e75af10cbbfab24bed7d39df64ecc4e9a13e121a6f4166308627d6","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-6.1 Sol","model_id":"gpt-6.1-sol","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-6d3d6189-43f2-56e0-b4c5-e5a6caf48ff3","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":90.4659090909091},"understanding":{"score":66.06060606060606}},"score":78.26325757575758,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":91},"内容完成度":{"score":85.46875},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":90.83333333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":60.833333333333336},"结构与推进":{"score":94.73958333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":33.333333333333336}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:fe3f135826f84ddd3e62dae96d072ca217f90437db1f42fae0bb3809e55e576a","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Doubao Seed 2.1 Pro (260915)","model_id":"doubao-seed-2-1-pro-260915","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"high","result_id":"result-71315105-9333-51ef-9582-d57288652fc8","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":70.64204545454545},"understanding":{"score":83.48484848484848}},"score":77.06344696969697,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":65.6875},"内容完成度":{"score":61.3125},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":66.52083333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":58.75},"结构与推进":{"score":87.39583333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:efa30f1d07c3c55767655bcd8a228d8d6263fa175a8122b828dea7a97ad576cd","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Kimi K3.1 Pro","model_id":"k3.1-pro","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-550eb1bb-0cd0-5939-af4c-3f1f9ca6310e","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":79.24431818181819},"understanding":{"score":74.77272727272727}},"score":77.00852272727273,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":70.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":63.21875},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":91.66666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":88.25},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":59.791666666666664},"结构与推进":{"score":92.23958333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:3598a6833e4f8a9f46364e65bed6702357dea500571849b83171f5113c13b12c","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GLM-5.3-Flash","model_id":"glm-5.3-flash","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-c43ee159-1128-5e0a-9bcb-afef49e84efd","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":71.75852272727273},"understanding":{"score":80.45454545454545}},"score":76.1065340909091,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":60.734375},"内容完成度":{"score":59.395833333333336},"意图与语境":{"score":85.41666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":83.33333333333333},"文体与场景适配":{"score":75.29166666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":86.875},"结构与推进":{"score":87.9375},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:c77bbbb8728bd07a7e4e3251ccd057fed6a3ce830d007395ef5c3067469558a3","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Gemini 3.8 Flash","model_id":"gemini-3-8-flash","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"high","result_id":"result-2a3a5757-a2a2-5518-a2f4-f68eabef8d2c","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":63.39772727272727},"understanding":{"score":88.71212121212122}},"score":76.05492424242425,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":50.1875},"内容完成度":{"score":52.427083333333336},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":69.86458333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":73.125},"结构与推进":{"score":76.70833333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:d6f57004057a89b226d18085dd311bbb4f272389fda7e023082500dcb091d852","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-6 Sol","model_id":"gpt-6-sol","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-ebe03b27-b2e7-51de-b5b7-12e2baedf1eb","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":82.04545454545455},"understanding":{"score":70}},"score":76.02272727272727,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":81.109375},"内容完成度":{"score":71.23958333333333},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":66.66666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":87.58333333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":63.333333333333336},"结构与推进":{"score":87.9375},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:07325c14b277d1ec6c69ea3bcfe24cb79dac11c2cfcbe3b7c98715f4903f7f86","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GLM-5.3","model_id":"glm-5.3","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-a5feeb15-84ad-5381-9a3b-3590db8fe18b","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":67.0284090909091},"understanding":{"score":84.92424242424242}},"score":75.97632575757575,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":60.734375},"内容完成度":{"score":50.270833333333336},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":83.33333333333333},"文体与场景适配":{"score":72.10416666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":71.04166666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":82.90625},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:c896bea1c7d86dd8927b5b27906891d2e8f704f7c5070681c32cc0580a81f1a8","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (1017)","model_id":"deepseek-flash","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-4415ee5b-6d4e-5928-822f-53e06ebb6e7a","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":73.05681818181819},"understanding":{"score":78.86363636363636}},"score":75.96022727272727,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":67.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":61.666666666666664},"意图与语境":{"score":85.41666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":76.625},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":74.16666666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":84.72916666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:e551e1ea2b1674b6b5c2d624ed4e007711b4560be465c53a70d84752f993039c","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Kimi K3","model_id":"k3","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-0f6ba19e-e792-5a79-b1f2-2c85c68e0ccd","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":66.02556818181819},"understanding":{"score":85.53030303030303}},"score":75.77793560606061,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":68.6875},"内容完成度":{"score":51.489583333333336},"意图与语境":{"score":93.75},"指令与边界":{"score":91.66666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":64},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":92.5},"结构与推进":{"score":80.8125},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:cb7de5320aeb7e0abc452caf6a4869de00462944486be7fb1e63f7f42b5ceebd","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (0910)","model_id":"deepseek-v4.1-flash-expires-on-0910","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-f67230ee-b40d-5b49-9d3c-ed9a8072bafe","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":74.80113636363636},"understanding":{"score":76.43939393939394}},"score":75.62026515151516,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":64.5625},"内容完成度":{"score":69.53125},"意图与语境":{"score":85.41666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":91.66666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":75.71875},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":71.66666666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":85.97916666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:366e5d8ad936d025d80e4140db0db1a4a72fb262e999be8b95f06927f0548fa2","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-5.6 Sol","model_id":"gpt-5.6-sol","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-9f3065ae-fb93-52b9-91ee-31197c03557f","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":77.35511363636364},"understanding":{"score":73.63636363636364}},"score":75.49573863636364,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":73.6875},"内容完成度":{"score":61.291666666666664},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":83.33333333333333},"文体与场景适配":{"score":89.58333333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":60.833333333333336},"结构与推进":{"score":83.63541666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:a5995be49c692ae9c8bb1950aabfc651d7fd474c7c2fd1ff3c982fd4cf3d0a24","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Grok 4.6","model_id":"grok-4.6","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"xhigh","result_id":"result-36421606-bbca-516b-88f2-ec2ca530f584","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":71.1903409090909},"understanding":{"score":79.77272727272727}},"score":75.4815340909091,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":61.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":65.52083333333333},"意图与语境":{"score":93.75},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":68.67708333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":72.5},"结构与推进":{"score":85.97916666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:37238e6e89978d81822a4713c8733301d94ec58be4025d33a318ffde0252b2d2","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"HY4 Dev","model_id":"hy4-dev","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"high","result_id":"result-508a43e2-c455-5ef5-90e6-7f31ace23904","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":70.25},"understanding":{"score":78.93939393939394}},"score":74.59469696969697,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":45.3125},"内容完成度":{"score":71.97916666666667},"意图与语境":{"score":93.75},"指令与边界":{"score":83.33333333333333},"文体与场景适配":{"score":72.625},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":78.54166666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":82.77083333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:9a201dbb2e404cca87d0497e8ea4e174b6215a1c28280e8de1d7b2e0719292d8","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"QoDuck","model_id":"qoduck","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"xhigh","result_id":"result-2ddca29b-5820-5258-ba77-a194458bfd4f","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":64.91477272727273},"understanding":{"score":76.51515151515152}},"score":70.71496212121212,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":52.734375},"内容完成度":{"score":51.489583333333336},"意图与语境":{"score":85.41666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":83.33333333333333},"文体与场景适配":{"score":73.86458333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":76.04166666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":77.51041666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:a519a84d57c4a930f9ae552a54973175775b56d28e6495ae24267a8d04a55490","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"MiMo-V2.6-Pro","model_id":"mimo-v2.6-pro","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"default","result_id":"result-0616da89-1646-5c9e-a8e9-2230cd754126","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":64.0340909090909},"understanding":{"score":74.62121212121212}},"score":69.32765151515152,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":60.5625},"内容完成度":{"score":42.239583333333336},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":73.04166666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":59.375},"结构与推进":{"score":79.13541666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:0b4e5eab0d51be5e173286c852bb2a74a57e8b5a407df57f69d3a264d8daaf2a","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"MiMo-V2.6-Flash","model_id":"mimo-v2-6-flash","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-b86503d8-bc07-5ab3-b57c-414212bcdd34","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":62.69602272727273},"understanding":{"score":74.46969696969697}},"score":68.58285984848484,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":53.25},"内容完成度":{"score":48.40625},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":66.10416666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":54.791666666666664},"结构与推进":{"score":79.875},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:dcb5a65ebb08bfce61fed05db623219699e40f901800188d59e1f396122a66a7","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-5.6 Terra","model_id":"gpt-5.6-terra","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-12a7175c-af10-5331-b583-b36a9f041c85","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":69.60511363636364},"understanding":{"score":62.42424242424242}},"score":66.01467803030303,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":69.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":48.114583333333336},"意图与语境":{"score":79.16666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":83.33333333333333},"文体与场景适配":{"score":75.86458333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":65.41666666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":85.05208333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":33.333333333333336}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:9ba3a97b28ac2db1a6f4b1561293207ddc7a9f2123f0934640b92dfff27750b7","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Qwen3.8-Flash","model_id":"qwen3.8-flash","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"xhigh","result_id":"result-03a34d3c-cf0f-5e37-8be5-9f046dafed7b","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":65.43181818181819},"understanding":{"score":64.84848484848484}},"score":65.14015151515152,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":63.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":52.083333333333336},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":91.66666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":71},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":57.5},"结构与推进":{"score":74.64583333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":33.333333333333336}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:b2c65d9199740fb88b7f9de57f21bed4949c0d575e29b9f00c568344918b3440","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-5.6 Luna","model_id":"gpt-5.6-luna","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-009040ee-719b-5c29-b500-e9cca628caa0","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":72.78977272727273},"understanding":{"score":54.09090909090909}},"score":63.44034090909091,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":63.90625},"内容完成度":{"score":64.65625},"意图与语境":{"score":85.41666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":79.16666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":76.26041666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":41.458333333333336},"结构与推进":{"score":83.375},"语义与事实":{"score":33.333333333333336}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:c2e564d4c24a41b57cc5ca761922bef34dbe97c8afa9b3cbb383c4b8b9b48c88","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"MiniMax M3.1 Flash","model_id":"MiniMax-M3.1-Flash","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-f66bac7e-5cda-5ffe-8fae-0f46ba677a3a","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":70.90056818181819},"understanding":{"score":55.45454545454545}},"score":63.17755681818182,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":64.6875},"内容完成度":{"score":66.91666666666667},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":66.13541666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":56.666666666666664},"结构与推进":{"score":83.79166666666667},"语义与事实":{"score":0}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:6ca4390682d617dd6768d465d0fdb78734c77578ad36193fb273ad0361adcf1a","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-6 Luna","model_id":"gpt-6-luna","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-028d650a-b58d-513e-bade-e28a93c8c1a5","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":68.55681818181819},"understanding":{"score":52.65151515151515}},"score":60.604166666666664,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":72.46875},"内容完成度":{"score":51.510416666666664},"意图与语境":{"score":85.41666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":75},"文体与场景适配":{"score":69.83333333333333},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":39.583333333333336},"结构与推进":{"score":81.71875},"语义与事实":{"score":33.333333333333336}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:0516749280495b204939ac4b80558063627c3914a5f0519931901ca5664596cd","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Claude Haiku 4.5","model_id":"claude-haiku-4-5","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-f235c1e4-5df3-560a-8157-18ab2f924915","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":47.30965909090909},"understanding":{"score":56.515151515151516}},"score":51.912405303030305,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":46.25},"内容完成度":{"score":27.75},"意图与语境":{"score":72.91666666666667},"指令与边界":{"score":79.16666666666667},"文体与场景适配":{"score":50.739583333333336},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":54.375},"结构与推进":{"score":64.14583333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":33.333333333333336}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:77838b7ac103c659c63947b2d7f038ec36997c46186076f6544373f59636c590","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Claude Fable 5.2","model_id":"claude-fable-5-2","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:a2fcb5b4e7ffc2cdee755b638dd42b781f72558d35306259763614b8b944912e","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-eaf68d02-5d86-5e20-b932-cfe89d2db943","score_origin":"reviewed_result","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":90.10227272727273},"understanding":{"score":97.57575757575759}},"score":93.83901515151516,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":80.46875},"内容完成度":{"score":89.47916666666667},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666666},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":91.41666666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":97.5},"结构与推进":{"score":95.83333333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":100}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:588e41b4762e792bf136b4a5ec2d554254f1e66bd2ae44f1a2d7e5137bdf875f","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"GPT-6.2 Astra","model_id":"gpt-6.2-astra","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:d8c22bd95ec1f2ae78fd9936de466ef4b98fe0bfed5c3dbce9f2cc15065ed0d9","reasoning_effort":"max","result_id":"result-17844e5d-fb9e-5fd0-a5bd-6e4899c19755","review_provenance":{"generation_variants":{"STR-05":{"max_output_tokens":65536,"previous_max_output_tokens":32768}},"label_en":"Independent supplementary review","label_zh":"子智能体补评","preserved_online_answers":12,"supplementary_review_answers":9},"score_origin":"independent_subagent_review","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":94.33806818181819},"understanding":{"score":80.9090909090909}},"score":87.62357954545455,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":90.109375},"内容完成度":{"score":90.41666666666667},"意图与语境":{"score":91.66666666666666},"指令与边界":{"score":100.0},"文体与场景适配":{"score":96.66666666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":76.66666666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":98.75},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:41f3a9af971b34c0f550f223e22069ddeaa0072051c84f6c0c7754f9b3fff412","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Qwen4-Max-Preview","model_id":"qwen4-max-preview","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:8c571c5278c72a63bc0f58fbbc6c20a42792b4697ca1915bf072cc8b181fa068","reasoning_effort":"default","result_id":"result-1f24c390-aab6-5116-81a1-f5ed9724ca1a","review_provenance":{"generation_variants":{"CNWBP11":{"max_output_tokens":65536,"previous_max_output_tokens":32768}},"label_en":"Preserved scores with missing-only supplementary review","label_zh":"保留原分并补齐缺失评分","preserved_online_answers":13,"supplementary_review_answers":8},"score_origin":"missing_only_local_sol_max_review","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":73.27272727272727},"understanding":{"score":83.33333333333333}},"score":78.3030303030303,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":66.28125},"内容完成度":{"score":62.760416666666664},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":83.33333333333334},"文体与场景适配":{"score":78.8125},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":87.5},"结构与推进":{"score":82.90625},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}},{"configuration_id":"sha256:cf4ce10a5a16ff54db4ac8b1feba73bc06cc184784b32813f6d2cb1e6bf9e15a","cycle_id":"zh-writing-22-v1-api-v1-action-feedback-50-50-v3","display_name":"Gemini 4 Hydrogen","model_id":"gemini-4-hydrogen","operation_sequence":0,"profile_id":"sha256:b5f2153914ccdb8673473ca6e510a08ecc7ebb0afc71158c1edac691232b009c","reasoning_effort":"default","result_id":"result-5ab72062-aab1-50e2-9077-4d42245220d2","summary":{"axes":{"output":{"score":73.26988636363636},"understanding":{"score":84.24242424242425}},"score":78.7561553030303,"subaxes":{"中文表达":{"score":59.734375},"内容完成度":{"score":65.08333333333333},"意图与语境":{"score":100},"指令与边界":{"score":100},"文体与场景适配":{"score":70.26041666666667},"材料综合与取舍":{"score":81.66666666666667},"结构与推进":{"score":93.48958333333333},"语义与事实":{"score":66.66666666666667}}}}],"schema_version":1}